Reporting quality of randomized controlled trials in prehabilitation: a scoping review

Engel, Dominique; Testa, Giuseppe Dario; McIsaac, Daniel I.; Carli, Francesco; Santa Mina, Daniel; Baldini, Gabriele; Scheede-Bergdahl, Celena; Chevalier, Stéphanie; Edgar, Linda; Beilstein, Christian M.; Huber, Markus; Fiore, Julio F.; Gillis, Chelsia

doi:10.1186/s13741-023-00338-8

Perioperative Medicine

Table 3 Agreement ratio for 70 randomized controlled trials of prehabilitation and 6 reporting guidelines

From: Reporting quality of randomized controlled trials in prehabilitation: a scoping review

Author	Year	Program	CONSORT	CERT	Modified-CERT	TIDieR	PRESENT	CONSORT-SPI
An J. et al.	2021	0	74	56	47	54
Argunova et al.	2022	0	31	46	33	46
Ausania et al.	2019	4	40	19	13	23	56
Barberan-Garcia at al.	2018	0	83	80	71	69
Berckel et al.	2022	0	78	63	50	62
Blackwell et al	2019	0	83	77	64	92
Bousquet-Dion et al.	2018	4	75	50	40	69	76	77
Brown et al.	2013	0	65	56	47	77
Brown et al.	2012	0	46	44	38	77
Calatayud et al.	2016	0	71	44	43	46
Carli et al.	2020	4	78	50	40	77	85	43
Carli et al.	2010	0	67	75	47	77
Dunne et al.	2014	0	81	40	43	46
Ferreira et al.	2020	4	89	88	80	92	85	69
Cavill et al.	2015	0	81	50	31	46
Ferreira et al.	2021	4	70	63	27	77	76	43
Fulop et al.	2021	4	72	36	29	42	82	7
Gillis et al.	2014	4	84	56	67	69	79	21
Gillis et al.	2014	1	89			77	85
Gloor et al.	2022	0	76	31	20	46
Gränicher et al.	2020	4	77	73	57	85
Grant et al.	2017	0	80	60	69	69
Gavier et al.	2021	0	68	53	40	54
Huang J. et al.	2017	4	75	53	36	62		14
Huang S. W. et al.	2011	0	58	25	20	31
Humeidan et al.	2021	5	89			62
Jahic et al.	2018	0	19	31	7	31
Jensen et al.	2014	0	78	44	20	69
Kim et al.	2009	0	49	50	20	69
Kim et al.	2021	0	63	27	25	46
Lai et al.	2016	4	66	33	27	46
Linang et al.	2018	4	83	50	27	46	79
Licker et al.	2016	0	92	53	33	54
Lindbäck et al.	2017	0	77	47	57	69
Liu et al.	2020	4	83	75	73	85	82	62
Lopez et al.	2021	4	56	31	13	46	62	62
Lotzke et al.	2019	5	84			54
Marchand et al.	2021	0	94	73	71	100
Mat Eli Ismail et al.	2016	0	56	40	27	50
Matassi et al.	2014	0	68	64	47	73
McIsaac et al.	2022	0	86	63	50	77
McKay et al.	2012	0	69	67	50	69
Minnella et al.	2021	4	78	73	33	85	85	64
Minnella et al.	2018	4	86	73	40	69	82
Minnella et al.	2020	4	89	64	47	77	85	64
Morano et al.	2013	4	58	25	27	46
Nguyen et al.	2022	0	86	63	50	75
Nielsen et al.	2010	0	78	38	27	54
Northgraves et al.	2020	0	77	87	73	92
O'Gara et al.	2020	5	78			62
Onerup et al.	2022	4	86	75	47	46
Peng et al.	2021	0	69	67	55	73
Sana Mina et al.	2018	0	74	56	27	62
Tenconi et al.	2021	4	77	38	19	50
Satoto et al.	2021	3	43	50	20	50
Sawatzky et al.	2014	0	66	60	19	69
Garcia et al.	2017	4	83	73	50	69
Shaarani et al.	2013	0	49	63	60	77
Steinmetz et al.	2020	0	64	53	50	46
Topp et al.	2009	0	34	44	27	42
Vagvolgyi et al.	2018	0	70	47	20	31
Hemink et al.	2020	1	78			67	68
Waller et al.	2022	4	78	56	20	54	76	36
Lai et al.	2017	4	74	47	29	38
Woodfield et al.	2021	0	83	80	69	92
Yamana et al.	2015	4	64	40	31	31
D'Lima et al.	1995	0	22	27	29	31
Rooks et al.	2006	0	56	53	33	77
Beaupre et al.	2004	0	60	53	50	62
Hulzebos et al.	2006	3	86	81	67	77

Type of program: exercise, 0; nutrition, 1; psychosocial, 2; functional, 3; multimodal, 4; cognitive training, 5. Consolidated Standards of Reporting of Trials, CONSORT 2010; Template for Intervention Description and Replication, TIDieR 2014; Consensus on Exercise Reporting Template, CERT 2016; Modified-CERT 2017; Proper Reporting of Evidence in Sport and Exercise Nutrition Trials, PRESENT 2020; CONSORT Extension for Psychosocial Interventions, CONSRT-SPI 2018

Back to article page

ISSN: 2047-0525

Contact us

Submission enquiries: journalsubmissions@springernature.com