Skip to main content

Table 9 Patient’s symptoms and experience on the gynae ward on day 1

From: Comparing the experience of enhanced recovery programme for gynaecological patients undergoing laparoscopic versus open gynaecological surgery: a prospective study

Variable

Procedure

Significance

Laparoscopy (N = 74)

Open (N = 70)

Have you taken tablets for pain relief?

 No

4 (5.4%)

0

p = 0.058

 Yes

61 (82.4%)

66 (94.3%)

 Missing data

9 (12.2%)

4 (5.7%)

Pain control

 Not at all

13 (17.6%)

0

 

 Mild

31 (41.9%)

18 (25.7%)

p = 0.000 *

 Moderate

22 (29.7%)

38 (54.3%)

 

 Severe

0

9 (12.9%)

 Missing data

8 (10.8%)

5 (7.1%)

Sickness control

 Not at all

51 (68.9%)

31 (44.2%)

 

 Occasionally

10 (13.5%)

20 (28.6%)

p = 0.003 *

 Most of the time

4 (5.4%)

13 (18.6%)

 Severe

3 (4.1%)

3 (4.3%)

 Missing data

6 (8.1%)

3 (4.3%)

Tiredness

 Not at all

8 (10.8%)

2 (2.9%)

 

 Occasionally

33 (44.6%)

33 (47.1%)

p = 0.158

 Most of the time

17 (23.0%)

25 (35.7%)

 Extremely

7 (9.4%)

6 (8.6%)

 Missing data

9 (12.2%)

4 (5.7%)

Are you confident to mobilise?

 Not at all

3 (4.1%)

14 (20.0%)

 

 Occasionally

10 (13.5%)

27 (38.6%)

p = 0.000 *

 Most of the time

20 (27.0%)

18 (25.7%)

 

 Completely

29 (39.2%)

6 (8.6%)

 Missing data

12 (16.2%)

5 (7.1%)

Are you confident to go home?

 Not at all

11 (14.9%)

40 (57.1%)

 

 Occasionally

8 (10.8%)

13 (18.5%)

p = 0.000 *

 Most of the time

7 (9.4%)

9 (12.9%)

 

 Completely

39 (52.7%)

6 (8.6%)

 Missing data

9 (12.2%)

2 (2.9%)

  1. *The above table shows there was better pain and nausea control in the laparoscopic group. In addition, the laparoscopic group was more able to dress independently and was more confident in mobilising and going home. However, the laparotomy group was more compliant with their breathing exercises